Home Equity Loan ? Still a Better Idea Than a 401(K) Loan


Anyone who borrows money is always looking for the cheapest source of funding. That makes sense; no one wants to pay more in interest than is absolutely necessary. And anyone with a sizeable amount of debt, such as credit card debt or a student loan, would be wise to consolidate their debt with a lower interest loan. One source of such a loan is a 401(K) account, which many consumers may have through their employer. Since the interest rate on Federal student loans rose on July 1, many students who missed that deadline may be wondering if consolidating through a 401(K) loan is a good alternative. Is it?

In a previous article, we have outlined several reasons why borrowing against a 401(K) account may be less favorable than using a home equity loan instead. The reasons include the fact that the interest on a 401(K) loan is not tax deductible, and that the borrower loses the ability for his or her investment to compound over time. If you have borrowed the money, it can't earn interest and the cost over twenty or thirty years could be dear. In addition to those, there are other reasons why a home equity loan would be a better source of consolidation funds.

The 401(K) loan is tempting. There is no credit check, the interest rate is usually favorable, and you are paying the interest back to yourself. The additional disadvantages are considerable, though. The money you borrow from your retirement account was money invested before taxes. The money you pay back is after-tax money, effectively increasing the amount that has to be paid back. Worse, should you lose your job, the 401(K) loan must be paid back immediately, in full. Should this not be possible, the loan is treated as a distribution, requiring the payment of a 10% penalty in addition to state and Federal taxes. With the job market still rather volatile, the additional risk of borrowing against a retirement account is substantial.

Borrowing against a tax-deferred retirement fund is rarely a good debt consolidation option. The tax disadvantages, the threat of penalties and immediate repayment and loss of compounding generally make such a loan a bad idea. Those with existing student loans should probably keep them; the interest is tax deductible and the rate is still lower than with most other consumer loans. For most anyone else, a home equity loan would be a better choice, offering deductible interest, fewer risks, and a fixed repayment schedule. Anyone considering a consolidation loan should consider all of these options carefully, as the cost of choosing poorly could be substantial.

©Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing. Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm devoted to informational Websites, including End-Your-Debt.com, a Website devoted to debt consolidation and credit counseling information and HomeEquityHelp.net, a site devoted to information on mortgages and home equity loans.







Related News



Mortgage crisis has turned homeownership upside down Homeowners ... - Chicago Tribune

Mortgage crisis has turned homeownership upside down Homeowners ...
Chicago Tribune, United States -42 minutes ago
"If you have some kind of disruption to your income and you can't make your mortgage payment, it's going to be very hard for you to refinance or anything ...

Reps Blunt And Frank Criticize McCain Mortgage Plan - ABC News

Reps Blunt And Frank Criticize McCain Mortgage Plan
ABC News -15 hours ago
John McCain's proposal to refinance distressed mortgages. "Not at face value, we're not going to buy up the mortgages at face value, because the people who ...
CQ Transcript: James Baker, Lawrence Summer, Rep. Barney Frank ...CQPolitics.com
all 3 news articles

McCain campaign outlines mortgage-rescue plan - San Francisco Chronicle

Wall Street Journal

McCain campaign outlines mortgage-rescue plan
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA -Oct 9, 2008
Barack Obama, McCain's Democratic rival, has proposed helping troubled homeowners refinance their mortgages, but his campaign attacked McCain's proposal for ...
Video: Obama: 'Taxpayers Shouldn't Pick Up Tab'AssociatedPress
Taxpayers, Not Lenders, Would Bear Costs of McCain’s Mortgage ProposalNew York Times
Principal is key to housing solutionWinston-Salem Journal
Newsday - St. Joseph News-Press
all 882 news articles

Avon Jittery As It Prepares To Refinance Debt - Hartford Courant

Avon Jittery As It Prepares To Refinance Debt
Hartford Courant, United States -Oct 12, 2008
... been struggling to process just $1 billion a week, a victim of the same credit strangulation that has stalled the mortgage and commercial paper markets. ...

McCain sells mortgage plan - Boston Globe

CTV.ca

McCain sells mortgage plan
Boston Globe, United States -Oct 11, 2008
Under his plan, the government would spend about $300 billion to buy distressed mortgages from financial institutions at their face values, then refinance...
What about the economy Obama, McCain? James KlurfeldNewsday
MY TURN: President Bush’s administration is not to blameTuscaloosa News (subscription)
all 968 news articles

Majority backs McCain’s $300B mortgage plan - Bizjournals.com

Wall Street Journal

Majority backs McCain’s $300B mortgage plan
Bizjournals.com, NC -Oct 10, 2008
John McCain, R-Ariz., that would have the federal government buy distressed and upside down mortgages and refinance them so homeowners can avoid ...
The Filter: Oct. 9, 2008Newsweek
all 1,760 news articles

From subprime to stock swoon - Globe and Mail

From subprime to stock swoon
Globe and Mail, Canada -13 minutes ago
Borrowers were led to believe that they would be able to refinance their homes at this point because the value of the property would have increased. ...

Freeport family battered by struggling economy - Newsday

Freeport family battered by struggling economy
Newsday, NY -15 minutes ago
Joan Fennell said her mortgage broker "promised" verbally she could refinance again within the year into a fixed-rate loan and she assumed she'd earn enough ...

ARM Holders Would Do Well to Shop Around Now - Washington Post

Sify

ARM Holders Would Do Well to Shop Around Now
Washington Post, United States -Oct 12, 2008
... lenders tighten their standards, and mortgage rates rise and fall, he wonders: What will happen when he has to refinance in 2010? ...
Letter: Economic trauma can't be excusedThe Delaware County Times
Bush: Don't Panic! At Least Not This Week, AnywayReason Online
EDITORIAL: Let Bailout Money Trickle Up, Not DownistockAnalyst.com (press release)
VDARE.com - SouthCoastToday.com
all 239 news articles


In market for a mortgage? - Portsmouth Herald News

In market for a mortgage?
Portsmouth Herald News, NH -21 hours ago
Since the Federal Reserve lowered short-term interest rates by half a percent recently, you might have an opportunity to refinance existing debt, ...